A friend of mine teaches remedial math at the Community College level. We were discussing the problem of a number of students who never seem to have their addition facts mastered (much less their multiplication facts). He wrote:
“I remember as a young math teacher wondering how many hours of flash card drill it takes in the elementary grades to become fluent in the addition and multiplication facts. I could imagine ten minutes a day of actual flash card drill, five days a week, for 45 weeks in one grade, a total of 50 hours if I multiplied correctly, might be a reasonable guess. Surely it has been studied. Well, if it has been studied I have never seen any evidence of it in the last fifty years. I thought of that as probably pretty basic knowledge about the teaching of arithmetic.”
I’d estimate that at least 30 hours of drill, spread over a period of time would be required for an average child to learn addition facts, and an equal amount of time later on to learn multiplication facts. But there is NO classroom time provided for this in the math curriculum.
The problem here, speaking as a third-grade teacher of 8-and-9-year-old students for a decade, is that the elementary math curriculum (in America) is not structured to provide ANY time for drill such as he describes. Even when I was a child in the early 1960’s, we did not have drill of that type in elementary school. My mother worked on flash cards with me 10-15 minutes every day before I was allowed to play. I HATED every moment of it, but saw the value of it when I got into the working world in my 20’s and was using multiplication every day, knowing my multiplication tables by heart thanks to her efforts.
I’ve been discussing math teaching with other math teachers for several years now, and I find there are several trends I highly disagree with.
Trend 1: The amount of math homework has been cut in half from 24-30 problems nightly, to 12-15. I can only guess that this has come about from parents complaining about too much homework over the years. While I am in favor of not giving more homework than necessary, unfortunately, the current lighter homework often does not give sufficient practice in a certain type of problem for the students to be able to understand or master that type of problem. One or two examples of a certain type of problem are just not sufficient.
Trend 2: Drill practice is considered “old-fashioned.” Never mind that the teacher can make drill practice into a fun lesson, just like any other type of lesson can be made fun by a a dedicated teacher. Without any drill, and without parents practicing or drilling children at home (such as the type of flash card practice my mother did with me as a child), many children are just NEVER mastering even the basic addition facts, let alone multiplication facts.
I no longer teach Grade 3; I am now a private tutor. Unfortunately, I am now running across a number of 14-year-olds who are using calculators to add 5 + 3, or 7 + 6, or 9 + 2. What’s even worse, THEIR TEACHERS LET THEM!!!! I personally think calculators should just be thrown out until about Grade 11, or whenever math involving higher functions on calculators is started. Prior to that time, they shouldn’t be allowed in school at all.
When I taught Grade 3, I made students show all of their work on their homework, including every carry number, and every cross-out for borrowing; I didn’t allow them to say, “I did it in my head.” (See photo above of example homework prior to 2007.) One reason for making students show all of their work (I had several reasons) is that I knew perfectly well many of them had calculators at home. However, even if they did their homework with calculators, they would have to redo it to mark all the carry numbers and borrowing cross-outs. This makes it better to just do it by hand in the first place. I then spent 30 minutes of my teaching time DAILY, going over these homework problems. It’s so satisfying to a teacher to hear, “Oh! Now I see my mistake!” It’s a big mistake for a teacher just to mark answers right or wrong, as students learn nothing from that.
Trend 3 (mostly at the high school level, I haven’t yet seen it appearing in middle schools, although I could be mistaken): Don’t instruct and explain, and then follow up with practice to master the skills. Instead, put students into groups, and let them see if they can “figure out themselves” how to do problems. Don’t give much feedback, but of course, students will have the same test as if you taught them the traditional way. (So the parents who can afford it get math tutors to do at home the job that the teacher should be doing; the parents who cannot afford tutors or understand the math themselves have children who completely fail math).
Trend 4 (has been around for at least 25 years): It doesn’t matter if children don’t master a unit. Just move through all the units, and the same units will be covered next year in a little more detail. If they still don’t get it, the same thing will happen the following year, and hopefully they will get it then. This idea has a name, which is called something like “spiraling.”
Even though I’ve never seen it, in the past couple of years I’ve become aware that “Singapore math” requires mastery of each math subject to a certain degree before moving on to the next math subject.
I think students would be far better served by having HALF the number of math topics (eliminating topics in Grade 2 such as Data, Graphing and Probablility; Congruent Shapes and Symmetry; etc.) and making sure they have mastered basic addition facts (by heart), addition and subtraction of two-digit numbers, and multiplication tables up to 5 (by heart) before moving into Grade 3. If parents don’t have time to drill children at home on these facts, then some time for it should be allowed in the school curriculum.
Other Math Posts by Lynne Diligent:
Tags: benefits of Singapore math, borrowing by crossing out, carrying by hand, community college remedial math, how much math homework should children have in Grade 2 or Grade 3, massive reduction in amount of nightly math homework, math curriculum wars in America, no time in the math curriculum for drill on learning basic math facts, number of hours of drill necessary to master basic math facts, should flash card drill be required, should parents drill children on basic math facts at home, should parents help with math homework, Some topics in the spiral math curriculum need to be eliminated, spiraling in the math curriculum is bad and does not work, the harmful effects of the spiral math curriculum, why aren't the math teachers doing their jobs, why aren't the math teachers teaching, why calculators should be banned in the elementary and middle school classrooms, why parents need to hire math tutors, why so many students need remedial math, why students are not masterning basic math facts, why the spiral math curriculum harms students